Voice privacy and security
Dictation App Permissions: Mic, Full Access, Clipboard
A dictation app needs the microphone to hear you. The second permission, which lets it put text into other apps, can reach much further than your voice: Full Access on an iPhone keyboard, Accessibility on a Mac, or the clipboard on any system. Grant each one only when the app needs it, and review them in your system's privacy settings.
Updated October 17, 202612 min read32 cited facts, each traced to its source
84keyboard apps
In a 2015 peer-reviewed study, 84 of 139 keyboard apps on Google Play could be misused as keyloggers.
Junsung Cho et al., 2015 13th Annual Conference on Privacy, Security and Trust (PST), IEEE, 2015
8vendors with critical flaws
Citizen Lab found critical vulnerabilities in keyboard apps from eight of the nine vendors it tested in 2024.
Citizen Lab, University of Toronto, 2024
139keyboard apps
The 2015 peer-reviewed study analyzed the security behaviors of 139 keyboard apps available on Google Play.
Junsung Cho et al., 2015 13th Annual Conference on Privacy, Security and Trust (PST), IEEE, 2015
A dictation app needs two kinds of access. The microphone lets it hear you. The second is the permission that lets it put the finished words where your cursor is, and that one can reach well beyond your voice. On an iPhone keyboard it is Allow Full Access. On a Mac it is Accessibility. On Windows it is input simulation, which Windows limits by integrity level. On any system the clipboard can carry your text to other apps. Grant the microphone when you dictate, grant the insertion permission only when the app needs it, and check both in your system's privacy settings.
This guide explains what each permission technically allows, according to Apple, Google and Microsoft, and how to review or revoke them. For the setup steps, see our guides to dictation on iPhone and dictation on a Mac. For the wider rules on where your voice is processed, start with our overview of voice privacy.
The microphone permission is the obvious one; the text insertion permission is the powerful one
The microphone permission controls whether an app can record your voice. On a Mac, Apple says you can decide which apps are allowed to use the microphone 1. On Windows 11, apps can use the microphone only when Microphone access is turned on under Privacy & security 2. Most people expect these switches, and they are easy to see in settings.
The insertion permission is different. It decides whether the app can act inside other apps: type into Notes, a browser or a chat window, or read what you have copied. Each platform gates this in its own way, so the table below sets the three main routes side by side.
| Route | Platform | What it lets the app do | Where you review it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Allow Full Access | iPhone and iPad keyboards | Lets a third-party keyboard use the network, which it cannot do by default | Settings, General, Keyboard, Keyboards, then the keyboard |
| Accessibility | Mac | Lets a named app see and operate other apps through accessibility features | System Settings, Privacy & Security, Accessibility |
| Input simulation | Windows | Sends keystrokes to other windows, but only to apps at an equal or lower integrity level | Not listed as a separate toggle in the sources we checked |
| Clipboard | All systems | Copies text that another app can read, subject to each system's rules | Depends on the system, covered below |
The table shows why the second permission deserves more attention. The microphone can only record. The insertion route can write, read or send text on your behalf.
Full access lets a phone keyboard reach the network, which is why iOS asks
On iPhone, Allow Full Access is the switch that gives a third-party keyboard network access. Apple says users must explicitly turn on the Allow Full Access switch for a keyboard in Settings before the keyboard can have open access 3. Until then, the keyboard runs in a sandbox. Apple's developer documentation says that sandbox's default configuration disallows network access 4. The setting belongs to each keyboard, so turning it on for one does not change the others. See the Allow Full Access glossary entry and the third-party keyboard definition for the terms.
Citizen Lab, an independent research lab, describes the same boundary. In its 2024 report it says that without this permission, third-party keyboards cannot transmit network data 5. This matters for dictation because a keyboard that sends your speech to a cloud engine, or downloads a model, needs a network connection. A keyboard that works fully on the phone may not need the switch at all.
Apple's warning is the reason the switch exists. As TechCrunch reported in 2014, Apple's warning says that if you enable Full Access, developers are permitted to access, collect and transmit the data you type 6. The wording is about permission. It does not say that every keyboard with the switch on collects your text.
Keyboard studies flagged most of the apps they tested
Two studies show how often the concern is real. They measure different things, so read them separately.
A 2015 peer-reviewed study analyzed the security behaviors of 139 keyboard apps on Google Play 7. It found that 84 of them could be misused as malicious keyloggers 8, which is 60 percent 9. That is a measure of what the apps could do, not of what they sent.
Citizen Lab's 2024 report tested keyboard apps from nine vendors, including Baidu, Huawei and Tencent 10. It found critical vulnerabilities in the apps of eight of those nine vendors 11, which is 89 percent 12. Those flaws let a network eavesdropper read keystrokes while they travel, which is a different threat from the vendor reading your text.
The two numbers are not comparable in a strict sense. One counts apps and the other counts vendors, and neither sample is a random sample of all keyboards. Read them as evidence that a third-party keyboard with network access deserves a check, not as a rating of any keyboard.
Citizen Lab also recommends that Android sandbox keyboard apps by default, as iOS does 13. It advises at-risk users to switch from a cloud-based keyboard app to one that operates entirely on-device 14. For more on that choice, see our guide to on-device speech recognition and the question on whether a third-party keyboard can see what you type.
On iPhone, a keyboard's voice typing runs inside the keyboard's own app
Keyboards on iPhone do not get the microphone themselves. In 2017, TechCrunch explained that Apple does not let third-party keyboards access the microphone, so Gboard's voice typing runs inside the Gboard app, which is allowed to use it 15. That report is nearly a decade old, so check the current behavior of any keyboard you use. The practical point stands: a keyboard that offers dictation may need both the app's microphone access and the network switch.
Accessibility access on a Mac lets an app read and control other apps
On a Mac, the Accessibility permission is the equivalent of Full Access for controlling other apps. Apple says that when a third-party app tries to access and control a Mac through accessibility features, the user receives an alert and must specifically grant the app access in Privacy & Security settings 16. Nothing is allowed by default. See the macOS Accessibility permission entry for the term.
The reason a dictation app asks is simple. To type into the app you have in front, it has to send keystrokes or text to that app. Accessibility is the channel macOS provides for that job. The same channel is used by assistive tools, and that is why the permission is powerful: a granted app can act across the apps on your Mac, not only in one window.
Apple's steps for reviewing it start from the Apple menu. To review app permissions, you choose Apple menu, System Settings, click Privacy & Security in the sidebar, then click Accessibility, and turn permission on or off for any app in the list 17. The question on why a dictation app needs Accessibility access on a Mac walks through the reasoning, and the Mac dictation privacy guide covers what Apple's own dictation keeps.
Paste-based insertion leaves your words on the clipboard, where other apps can read them
Some dictation apps avoid Accessibility entirely. They copy the finished text to the clipboard and send a paste command, so you or the app presses Command-V or Control-V. That trades one permission for another, because the clipboard is a shared place that other apps can try to read. How safe it is depends on the operating system.
On iPhone, Apple's 2022 developer session explained that from iOS 16 the system confirms intent before one app reads pasteboard items written by another app 18. Apple's session describes the design intent, so the exact prompt wording and when it appears can change between versions.
On Android, Google's documentation shows that protection has been added over time. Android versions older than Android 10 let background applications access foreground app clipboard information 19. From Android 12, a toast appears each time an app accesses clipboard data and pastes it, which Google says makes attacks more difficult to go unnoticed 20. A phone on an older Android version is therefore a weaker place to keep dictated text on the clipboard.
On Windows, the input route is different. The SendInput function is subject to User Interface Privilege Isolation, so applications can inject input only into applications at an equal or lesser integrity level 21. This does not stop a dictation app from typing into an ordinary window, but it does mean that text can fail to reach a window that runs with elevated rights. Windows does not list this as a separate privacy switch in the sources we checked.
| Platform | Clipboard protection in the sources | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| iPhone, iPad | The system confirms intent before one app reads another app's copied items (iOS 16 and later) | Answer the prompt only for the app you are using |
| Android | Background access blocked from Android 10; toast shown from Android 12 | Use Android 12 or later, and treat the toast as a notice worth reading |
| Windows | Clipboard history can sync to other devices when you turn it on | Check the sync setting, covered next |
| Mac | Universal Clipboard copies between your own devices | Turn it off if you do not need it |
The table lists the protections the sources describe. The sources did not settle whether macOS shows a clipboard prompt for every app, so check Apple's current developer documentation before relying on one.
Clipboard history and sync can copy dictated text to other devices
Clipboard history and sync are where paste-based dictation can leave your device. On Windows, Microsoft says you can sync your clipboard history to the cloud and paste items from it 22. Sync is controlled in Settings under System, then Clipboard, and the toggle is labeled Clipboard history across your devices. Microsoft also says the feature is tied to your Microsoft account or your work account, so the same login must be used on every device 23. If you dictate on a shared machine, check that sync is off.
On Apple devices, Universal Clipboard copies between your devices. Apple says it needs both devices to be signed in to the same Apple Account 24, and it says that copied content is available on the Clipboard for a short time, so you should paste it soon after copying 25. Apple describes it as best for small selections of text or copied images between devices 26. The rule of thumb is simple: if you do not want your dictated text to appear on another device, turn Universal Clipboard off in the settings for the devices you use.
Recording indicators show when any app is using the microphone
The microphone permission is only half the check. Each system shows a visible sign when the microphone is in use, and it is worth knowing where to look.
On iPhone, Apple says that with iOS 14 or later, an orange dot, an orange square, or a green dot indicates when the microphone or camera is being used by an app 27. The orange indicator means the microphone is in use. It appears as a square when Differentiate Without Color is turned on in Settings, under Accessibility, then Display & Text Size 28. A green indicator means the camera alone, or the camera and microphone together, is in use.
On a Mac, the Recording Indicator light in Control Center shows when the microphone is in use or has been used recently 29. The "used recently" part matters. A light that is off now does not prove that no app recorded earlier.
On Windows, the device-level check comes first. Apps can use the microphone only when Microphone access is turned on under Privacy & security, App permissions, Microphone 2. On Windows 11, you must also turn on Let apps access your microphone 30. Desktop apps have a separate setting, Let desktop apps access your microphone, which must be turned on for them to use the microphone 31. The question on how to tell if an app is using your microphone covers the indicators in more detail.
Audit and revoke permissions in each operating system's privacy settings
Review your permissions on a schedule, and every time you install a new dictation app. The steps below use the menu names from the sources we checked. Platform screens change between releases, so if a name differs on your version, look for the same setting nearby.
- On iPhone, open Settings, tap General, tap Keyboard, tap Keyboards, and then tap the keyboard. Apple's steps for adding and changing keyboards follow the same path 32. Turn off Allow Full Access for any keyboard you no longer use for speech.
- On a Mac, choose Apple menu > System Settings, click Privacy & Security, and then open Accessibility. Turn off access for any app you no longer trust to control your Mac 17. Then open Microphone and review the list of apps 1.
- On Windows 11, open Start, Settings, Privacy & security, then Microphone. Check the device-level Microphone access setting, the Let apps access your microphone switch, and the Let desktop apps access your microphone switch 30.
- On Windows clipboard history, open Settings, System, Clipboard. Turn off the sync toggle if you do not want copied items on other devices.
- On Android, the sources we checked do not give a single settings path for keyboard network access, so check the keyboard app's own settings and the phone's app permissions for the microphone. Prefer an on-device keyboard for sensitive speech, as Citizen Lab advises 14.
Revoking a permission stops future access. To ask what an app has already received or stored, use its privacy policy and data controls. The question on whether apps can read your clipboard covers the clipboard rules in short form.
How to decide which permissions a dictation app needs
Use three questions. Does the app need the microphone to hear you? If yes, grant it. Does it need to type into other apps? If it uses a keyboard, grant Full Access only if the keyboard must reach the network. If it uses Accessibility on a Mac, grant that only to an app you trust. Does it paste through the clipboard? Then check the sync and history settings on each device.
We make Yap, a dictation app for Mac and Windows that also runs on phones. Check its permission list against these same questions, as you would any app, and check the other apps you consider with the same three questions. A good dictation app should explain in its settings or privacy policy why it needs each permission. If it cannot, that is a reason to look elsewhere.
For the full picture of where your voice is processed, read our guide on whether voice to text is safe, the guide on whether dictation apps train AI on your voice, and the guide to voice data retention. For the Windows side, see our Windows dictation privacy guide.
Evidence
Every number on this page, with where it comes from. Open a fact to see the exact words in its source.
- 1.
- 2.
- 3.
- 4.
- 5.
- 6.
- 7.
- 8.
- 9.In the 2015 study, 84 of 139 keyboard apps, or 60 percent, could be misused as keyloggers.
Calculated from 2 other facts
- 10.
- 11.
- 12.Eight of nine vendors tested in the 2024 Citizen Lab report had critical flaws, which is 89 percent.
Calculated from 2 other facts
- 13.
- 14.
- 15.
- 16.
- 17.
- 18.
- 19.
- 20.
- 21.
- 22.
- 23.
- 24.
- 25.
- 26.
- 27.
- 28.
- 29.
- 30.
- 31.
- 32.
Questions about this
- Are open-source offline dictation apps like Handy and Murmur safe to use?Generally yes. Handy and Murmure, the app people often search for as Murmur, are designed to transcribe on your own computer, and their code is public. Their safety in practice depends on three more things: downloading only from the official release page, checking that your operating system can verify the file, and granting only the permissions the app needs.
- Can a third-party keyboard see what you type?A third-party keyboard sees the characters you type into ordinary fields, because it produces them. On an iPhone it cannot send that text over the network unless you turn on Allow Full Access for it, and the system keyboard handles password fields. With Full Access on, Apple warns that the developer may collect and transmit what you type, so read that keyboard's privacy policy before you turn the switch on.
- Can apps read your clipboard?Yes. Whether an app can read what you copied depends on the system: iPhone asks for your intent before one app reads what another app copied (from iOS 16), and Android 12 and later show a notice each time an app pastes clipboard data. Clipboard sync and Universal Clipboard can also copy dictated text to your other devices, so turn them off where you do not need them.
- How can you tell if an app is using your microphone?Look for the indicator your system shows, then check the app list in its privacy settings. On an iPhone, an orange indicator in the status bar means an app is using the microphone. On a Mac, the Recording Indicator in Control Center shows when the microphone is in use or has been used recently. On Windows 11, apps can use the microphone only when Microphone access is on, so check those switches.
- Why does a dictation app need Accessibility access on a Mac?Accessibility is the permission macOS uses to let one app access and control other apps through accessibility features. A dictation app that types into the window you are using needs a route like this, so macOS blocks it until you grant it in Privacy & Security settings. The grant reaches more than your voice, so allow it only for a dictation app you know and trust.
More in Voice privacy and security
- Speech to Text Privacy: Where Your Voice GoesThe overview of this topic
- Is Voice to Text Safe? How to Dictate Privately
- Voice Data Retention: What Apple, Google and Microsoft Keep
- Is Whisper AI Safe? Privacy and Security Explained
- Is Dictation HIPAA Compliant? What Makes It Safe
- Is Your Voice Biometric Data? GDPR, BIPA and CCPA
- Do Dictation Apps Train AI on Your Voice?
- Do Companies Listen to Your Voice Recordings?
- Recording Consent Laws: One-Party vs All-Party States
- Voice Cloning and Deepfakes: Risks and Protection
- Dictation for Lawyers: Privilege and Confidentiality
- Dictation at Work: Enterprise and Government Policies
Referenced by
- Speech to Text Privacy: Where Your Voice GoesTopic
- How to Turn On Voice Typing on Every DeviceGuide
- Are open-source offline dictation apps like Handy and Murmur safe to use?Question
- Can a third-party keyboard see what you type?Question
- Can apps read your clipboard?Question
- How can you tell if an app is using your microphone?Question
- Is it safe to dictate passwords and sensitive information?Question
- Why does a dictation app need Accessibility access on a Mac?Question
- Accessibility permission (macOS)Glossary
- False accept (accidental activation)Glossary